Irrealis moods¶
Moods¶
Subjunctive¶
Event is considered unlikely (mainly used in dependent clauses).
Conditional¶
Event depends upon another condition.
Optative¶
Event is hoped, expected, or awaited.
Jussive¶
Event is pleaded, implored or asked.
Potential¶
Event is probable or considered likely
Imperative/Prohibitive¶
Event is directly ordered or requested by the speaker.
Event is directly prohibited by the speaker.
Desiderative¶
Event is desired/wished by a participant in the state of affairs referred to in the utterance
Dubitative¶
Event is uncertain, doubtful, dubious.
Hypothetical¶
Event is hypothetical, or it is counterfactual, but possible
Presumptive¶
Event is assumed, presupposed by the speaker.
Permissive¶
Event is permitted by the speaker
Hortative¶
Event is exhorted, implored, insisted or encouraged by speaker.
Eventive¶
Event is likely but depends upon a condition; a combination of the potential and conditional.
Preactive¶
Event is requested by the speaker.
Volitive¶
Event is desired, wished or feared by the speaker
Interrogative¶
Event is asked or questioned by the speaker
Benedictive¶
Event is requested or wished by the speaker in a polite or honorific fashion.
Concessive¶
Event is presupposed or admitted as part of a refutation.
Prescriptive¶
Event is prescribed by the speaker (though not demanded), but with the expectation that it will occur.
Apprehensive¶
Event is warned against happening.
Mood examples in English¶
Mood |
Core Meaning |
Simple English Example |
English Construction / Verb Form |
Why This Construction Fits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Subjunctive |
Required, mandated, necessary |
It is essential that she be present. |
Mandative subjunctive: finite content clause with the plain form. |
The plain form suppresses ordinary tense/agreement and presents the event as a requirement rather than a fact. |
Conditional |
Depends on a condition |
If it rains, we will stay inside. |
if-clause + main clause. |
The construction explicitly links one event to the fulfillment of another condition. |
Optative |
Hope or expectation |
May you succeed. |
Formulaic may + bare infinitive. |
May presents the event as desired rather than actual. |
Jussive |
Request, plea, exhortation |
Let him speak. |
let + NP + bare infinitive. |
The speaker seeks to bring about an event without directly commanding the participant. |
Potential |
Likely or possible |
She may arrive soon. |
Modal auxiliary (may, might, could). |
Modal verbs naturally encode possibility rather than actuality. |
Imperative |
Direct command |
Close the door. |
Imperative clause with plain form. |
The clause directly attempts to cause the event. |
Prohibitive |
Direct prohibition |
Don’t touch that. |
Negative imperative. |
The speaker directly attempts to prevent the event. |
Desiderative |
Desire of a participant |
I want to travel abroad. |
Verb of desire + infinitival clause. |
The matrix verb (want) explicitly identifies the participant’s desire toward the event. |
Dubitative |
Doubt or uncertainty |
Perhaps he is mistaken. |
Adverbs (perhaps) or modals (might). |
These forms mark the proposition as uncertain rather than established. |
Hypothetical |
Imagined or counterfactual situation |
Suppose you won the lottery. |
Suppose clause; often modal remoteness. |
The construction invites consideration of a non-actual scenario. |
Presumptive |
Assumed by the speaker |
He must be at home by now. |
Epistemic modal (must). |
The modal marks the proposition as inferred rather than directly known. |
Permissive |
Permission granted |
You may leave now. |
Permission modal (may, can). |
The modal explicitly removes a restriction on the event. |
Hortative |
Encouragement including the speaker |
Let’s begin. |
let’s + bare infinitive. |
The construction proposes a joint course of action involving the speaker. |
Eventive |
Likely if a condition is met |
If the weather improves, the crops should thrive. |
Conditional construction + likelihood modal. |
The event is presented as contingent yet probable. |
Preactive |
Request for future action |
Please send me the report tomorrow. |
Polite imperative or modal request. |
The construction seeks to influence a future action without issuing a strong command. |
Volitive |
Speaker’s wish, desire, or fear |
I hope she returns safely. |
Verb expressing wish/fear + content clause. |
The matrix verb directly expresses the speaker’s attitude toward the event. |
Interrogative |
Questioning |
Did she arrive yet? |
Interrogative clause with inversion. |
The speaker requests information about whether the event occurred. |
Benedictive |
Formal blessing or good wish |
May God bless you. |
Formulaic may + bare infinitive. |
The event is presented as a desired outcome, often invoking a higher power. |
Concessive |
Admission before refutation |
Even if he is right, we should proceed cautiously. |
Concessive clause (even if, although). |
The construction temporarily grants a proposition while denying its relevance to the conclusion. |
Prescriptive |
Recommendation with expectation |
You should submit the application today. |
Deontic modal (should, ought to). |
The modal presents the event as advisable rather than mandatory. |
Apprehensive |
Fear or warning about a possible event |
Be careful lest you fall. |
Warning expression; often lest + plain form. |
The construction highlights an undesirable event that the speaker seeks to prevent. |
How English express moods¶
Family |
Why English Uses These Constructions |
|---|---|
Commands (Imperative, Prohibitive, Jussive, Hortative, Preactive) |
They are all attempts to influence behavior, so English uses directive constructions (close the door, let him speak, please send…). |
Requirements & Recommendations (Subjunctive, Permissive, Prescriptive) |
They regulate what ought to happen, so English uses deontic devices (be present, may leave, should apply). |
Possibility & Knowledge (Potential, Dubitative, Presumptive) |
They concern certainty and evidence, so English relies on modal auxiliaries (may, might, must). |
Desire & Wishes (Optative, Desiderative, Volitive, Benedictive, Apprehensive) |
They express attitudes toward events, so English uses verbs of wishing/fearing or the formulaic may. |
Alternative Worlds (Conditional, Hypothetical, Eventive, Concessive) |
They describe events in relation to assumptions or conditions, so English uses subordinate clauses (if, suppose, even if). |
Information Seeking (Interrogative) |
It is not about the event itself but about obtaining information regarding it. |
Mapping modal verbs to moods¶
Moods centered mood-modal table¶
Mood |
Typical English Devices |
Modal Domain |
|---|---|---|
Subjunctive |
must, should, mandative subjunctive (that she be) |
Deontic necessity |
Conditional |
if, would, will, could |
Conditionality |
Optative |
may, wish, hope |
Bouletic (wish) |
Jussive |
let, must, should |
Directive / deontic |
Potential |
may, might, could, can |
Epistemic or dynamic possibility |
Imperative |
no modal; imperative clause |
Directive |
Prohibitive |
mustn’t, don’t |
Deontic prohibition |
Desiderative |
want, wish, would like |
Bouletic (desire) |
Dubitative |
may, might, perhaps, possibly |
Epistemic uncertainty |
Hypothetical |
would, could, might |
Remote modality |
Presumptive |
must, should, ought to |
Epistemic inference |
Permissive |
may, can |
Deontic permission |
Hortative |
let’s, shall we |
Directive |
Eventive |
should, will, may (in conditionals) |
Conditional + epistemic |
Preactive |
could you, would you, please |
Directive |
Volitive |
hope, wish, fear |
Bouletic |
Interrogative |
modal depends on question |
Not inherently modal |
Benedictive |
may |
Bouletic |
Concessive |
even if, although |
Not inherently modal |
Prescriptive |
should, ought to |
Weak deontic |
Apprehensive |
might, lest, for fear that |
Epistemic possibility + negative desire |
English centered modal-mood table¶
English Modal Center |
Related Moods |
|---|---|
must |
Subjunctive, Jussive, Prohibitive, Presumptive |
should / ought to |
Prescriptive, Eventive, weak Subjunctive |
may |
Potential, Permissive, Optative, Benedictive |
might |
Dubitative, Potential, Apprehensive |
would |
Conditional, Hypothetical |
could |
Potential, Hypothetical, Preactive |
let |
Jussive, Hortative |
hope / wish / want / fear |
Volitive, Optative, Desiderative, Apprehensive |
English modal verbs by semantic territory¶
may¶
The modal most strongly associated with irrealis meanings.
She may arrive soon (potential) You may leave now. (permissive) May you prosper (optative) May god bless you (benedictive) It may be true (dubitative)
Core meaning:
The proposition is possible, permitted, or wished for, but not asserted as fact.
might¶
Typically expresses a more remote or uncertain possibility than may.
She might arrive later. (potential)
He might be wrong. (dubitative)
In different circumstances, she might succeed. (hypothetical)
Core meaning:
The speaker assigns a lower degree of commitment to the proposition.
must¶
Has two major uses: deontic necessity and epistemic inference.
Applicants must submit a form. (Requirement, subjunctive oriented)
You must leave immediately. (directive insistence)
He must be home by now. (Presumptive)
Core meaning:
The proposition is either necessary or strongly inferred.
Note
English “must” does not distinguish requirement and command grammatically.
should¶
One of the most versatile irrealis markers.
You should apply. (prescriptive)
If conditions improve, production should increase. (eventive, should is stronger so the possibility of the event to occur is higher)
They should be home by now. (presumptive)
It is important that she should attend. (mandative, especially BrE)
Core meaning:
The proposition is advisable, expected, or probable.
would¶
The principal marker of modal remoteness.
I would go if I could. (conditional)
Imagine what would happen if we failed. (hypothetical)
Would that it were true! (hypothetical)
Core meaning:
The proposition is viewed from a non-actual or dependent perspective.
could¶
Bridges possibility, ability, and hypotheticality.
She could arrive tomorrow. (potential)
If we hurried, we could catch the train. (hypothetical)
Could you help me? (preactive request)
Core meaning:
The proposition is possible given certain circumstances.
can¶
Primarily expresses ability or permission.
You can leave now. (permissive)
This can happen. (dynamic potential)
She can swim. (ability)
Core meaning:
The subject has the ability, opportunity, or permission for the event.
Common mandative verbs¶
Semantic class |
Examples |
|---|---|
Directives |
insist, demand, order, command |
Recommendations |
suggest, recommend, propose |
Requirements |
require, stipulate |
Importance/necessity adjectives |
essential, important, vital |