Viewpoint

The following table shows closely related situations in the same primary tense (past), but with different combinations of perfect and progressive marking:

Form

Viewpoint

Sentence

What It Communicates

Non-progressive

Often perfective with a telic event

She built the house.

The event is presented as a bounded whole. With this telic predicate, the house is understood to be finished.

Progressive

Imperfective

She was building the house.

The event is viewed from within. It may never have been finished.

Perfect

Often perfective with a telic event

She had built the house.

The building is anterior to another past reference point; with this telic predicate, completion is understood.

Perfect + Progressive

Imperfective

She had been building the house.

The building process was ongoing before a past reference point; completion is not asserted.

Note

Perfective and imperfective are useful semantic viewpoint terms here.

They are not the grammatical aspect opposition recognised by CGEL for English.

CGEL grammatical aspect = progressive vs non-progressive.

Aspect and tense in English

Tense

Perfect?

Aspect

Viewpoint

Sentence

What It Communicates

Past

Non-perfect

Non-progressive

Often perfective

She built the house.

The event is presented as a complete whole. With this telic predicate, the house is understood to be finished.

Past

Non-perfect

Progressive

Imperfective

She was building the house.

The event is viewed from within, as ongoing at a particular time. Completion is not implied.

Past

Perfect

Non-progressive

Often perfective

She had built the house.

The building is anterior to another past reference point; the endpoint is understood to have been reached.

Past

Perfect

Progressive

Imperfective

She had been building the house.

The building activity was in progress before another past reference point, often emphasising its duration.

Present

Non-perfect

Non-progressive

Context-dependent

She builds houses.

Typically expresses a habit or generalisation rather than adopting a bounded-event viewpoint.

Present

Non-perfect

Progressive

Imperfective

She is building the house.

The building is currently in progress. Completion is not implied.

Present

Perfect

Non-progressive

Often perfective with this predicate

She has built the house.

The building is anterior to the present; with this telic predicate, completion is understood.

Present

Perfect

Progressive

Imperfective

She has been building the house.

The building activity began earlier and has continued up to or close to the present, emphasising duration or continuity.

Lexical and context

Lexical aspect describes the inherent temporal character of a situation as determined by the predicate and context. Perfective/imperfective viewpoint is influenced by lexical aspect, but not derived from it.

This is not “CGEL grammatical aspect”, but a viewpoint.

  • Stative/dynamic

  • Telic/atelic

  • Durative/punctual

These properties strongly influence whether a clause receives a perfective or imperfective interpretation.

For example:

  • States naturally favour imperfective interpretation

  • Telic dynamic predicates readily support perfective interpretation when non-progressive

  • Progressive marking strongly favours imperfective interpretation

Lexical aspect constrains and biases the viewpoint, but does not determine it by itself.

Aspectual analysis

The following concerns lexical aspect / situation type rather than the grammatical progressive vs non-progressive contrast.

Primitive of aspectual features

Dynamism (+/- dynamic)

  • Dynamic (+): Involves internal change, transition, or input of energy over time. Without continuous energy or action, the situation ceases (e.g., run, build, fall).

  • Static (-): Involves no internal change or development. The situation remains relatively constant across its temporal span (e.g., know, resemble, be tall).

Duration (+/- durative)

  • Durative (+): Occupies a meaningful temporal interval (e.g., sleep, read, walk).

  • Punctual (-): Is conceptualised as occurring at or near a single temporal point, with little meaningful internal duration (e.g., explode, blink, notice).

Telicity (+/- telic)

  • Telic (+): Bounded by an inherent logical endpoint or goal (telos). Reaching the endpoint completes the event (e.g., cross the street, build a house).

  • Atelic (-): Has no inherent endpoint. The situation can continue or stop without reaching a built-in culmination (e.g., sing, rain, exist).

Mereological properties (part-whole mechanics)

Analogous to the mass/count noun distinction, aspectual types have useful part-whole properties concerning how situations relate to their subparts.

Homogeneity (sub-interval property)

If you walked from 2:00 to 3:00, you were also walking from 2:15 to 2:30.

  • Definition: A predicate P is homogeneous if ordinary sub-intervals of an interval where P holds can also count as P.

  • Distribution: States and atelic activities tend to be homogeneous.

Quantisation (heterogeneity)

If you drew a circle between 2:00 and 2:05, a 30-second sub-interval in the middle does not itself constitute "drawing a circle."

  • Definition: A predicate P is quantised if no proper subpart of an event satisfying P normally counts as another complete event satisfying P.

  • Distribution: Telic predicates such as accomplishments and achievements tend to be quantised.