Viewpoint¶
The following table shows closely related situations in the same primary tense (past), but with different combinations of perfect and progressive marking:
Form |
Viewpoint |
Sentence |
What It Communicates |
|---|---|---|---|
Non-progressive |
Often perfective with a telic event |
She built the house. |
The event is presented as a bounded whole. With this telic predicate, the house is understood to be finished. |
Progressive |
Imperfective |
She was building the house. |
The event is viewed from within. It may never have been finished. |
Perfect |
Often perfective with a telic event |
She had built the house. |
The building is anterior to another past reference point; with this telic predicate, completion is understood. |
Perfect + Progressive |
Imperfective |
She had been building the house. |
The building process was ongoing before a past reference point; completion is not asserted. |
Note
Perfective and imperfective are useful semantic viewpoint terms here.
They are not the grammatical aspect opposition recognised by CGEL for English.
CGEL grammatical aspect = progressive vs non-progressive.
Aspect and tense in English¶
Tense |
Perfect? |
Aspect |
Viewpoint |
Sentence |
What It Communicates |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Past |
Non-perfect |
Non-progressive |
Often perfective |
She built the house. |
The event is presented as a complete whole. With this telic predicate, the house is understood to be finished. |
Past |
Non-perfect |
Progressive |
Imperfective |
She was building the house. |
The event is viewed from within, as ongoing at a particular time. Completion is not implied. |
Past |
Perfect |
Non-progressive |
Often perfective |
She had built the house. |
The building is anterior to another past reference point; the endpoint is understood to have been reached. |
Past |
Perfect |
Progressive |
Imperfective |
She had been building the house. |
The building activity was in progress before another past reference point, often emphasising its duration. |
Present |
Non-perfect |
Non-progressive |
Context-dependent |
She builds houses. |
Typically expresses a habit or generalisation rather than adopting a bounded-event viewpoint. |
Present |
Non-perfect |
Progressive |
Imperfective |
She is building the house. |
The building is currently in progress. Completion is not implied. |
Present |
Perfect |
Non-progressive |
Often perfective with this predicate |
She has built the house. |
The building is anterior to the present; with this telic predicate, completion is understood. |
Present |
Perfect |
Progressive |
Imperfective |
She has been building the house. |
The building activity began earlier and has continued up to or close to the present, emphasising duration or continuity. |
Lexical and context¶
Lexical aspect describes the inherent temporal character of a situation as determined by the predicate and context. Perfective/imperfective viewpoint is influenced by lexical aspect, but not derived from it.
This is not “CGEL grammatical aspect”, but a viewpoint.
Stative/dynamic
Telic/atelic
Durative/punctual
These properties strongly influence whether a clause receives a perfective or imperfective interpretation.
For example:
States naturally favour imperfective interpretation
Telic dynamic predicates readily support perfective interpretation when non-progressive
Progressive marking strongly favours imperfective interpretation
Lexical aspect constrains and biases the viewpoint, but does not determine it by itself.
Aspectual analysis¶
The following concerns lexical aspect / situation type rather than the grammatical progressive vs non-progressive contrast.
Primitive of aspectual features¶
Dynamism (+/- dynamic)¶
Dynamic (+): Involves internal change, transition, or input of energy over time. Without continuous energy or action, the situation ceases (e.g., run, build, fall).
Static (-): Involves no internal change or development. The situation remains relatively constant across its temporal span (e.g., know, resemble, be tall).
Duration (+/- durative)¶
Durative (+): Occupies a meaningful temporal interval (e.g., sleep, read, walk).
Punctual (-): Is conceptualised as occurring at or near a single temporal point, with little meaningful internal duration (e.g., explode, blink, notice).
Telicity (+/- telic)¶
Telic (+): Bounded by an inherent logical endpoint or goal (telos). Reaching the endpoint completes the event (e.g., cross the street, build a house).
Atelic (-): Has no inherent endpoint. The situation can continue or stop without reaching a built-in culmination (e.g., sing, rain, exist).
Mereological properties (part-whole mechanics)¶
Analogous to the mass/count noun distinction, aspectual types have useful part-whole properties concerning how situations relate to their subparts.
Homogeneity (sub-interval property)¶
If you walked from 2:00 to 3:00, you were also walking from 2:15 to 2:30.
Definition: A predicate P is homogeneous if ordinary sub-intervals of an interval where P holds can also count as P.
Distribution: States and atelic activities tend to be homogeneous.
Quantisation (heterogeneity)¶
If you drew a circle between 2:00 and 2:05, a 30-second sub-interval in the middle does not itself constitute "drawing a circle."
Definition: A predicate P is quantised if no proper subpart of an event satisfying P normally counts as another complete event satisfying P.
Distribution: Telic predicates such as accomplishments and achievements tend to be quantised.